Crime Fiction Ratings

by The Purloined Letter Society (International)

Catalogue   Click here to read our mission statement

Ratings:

1 star Of some literary quality
2 star Of substantial literary quality
3 star Exceptional

Keys:

(T) Translated from language other than English
PI Private investigator
PO Police officer(s)
O Other

Showing 1 to 20 of 157 authors.

Page:  

            Authors per page:  

            Search:  

 

 

List:   Main  |  Supplementary

Main List

Author   Rating   Char.   Place   Period   Additonal Information
Gulick, Robert van O China 1200's (?) Set in medieval China. Investigator is a magistrate.
Hilton, John Buxton PO England 1870's - 1970's Historical novels are more interesting than the contemporary ones.
Conan Doyle, Arthur PI England (mainly) 1880's - 1900's Only short stories featuring 'Sherlock Holmes' are rated *.
Chesterton, G K O UK & Europe 1910's - 1920's Only stories featuring 'Father Brown' are rated **
Sayers, Dorothy O UK 1910's - 1940's Only "Nine Tailors" and "Gaudy Night" are rated **. All others are rated *.
Dine, S S van O USA (East Coast) 1920's - 1930's "Upper-class" settings; convoluted plotting.
Freeman, Austin O England 1920's - 1930's
Hammett, Dashiel PI USA (California) 1920's - 1940's
Upfield, Arthur PO Australia 1920's - 1950's Writing style naive; characterisations sentimental, ingenuous. Only novels set in the outback and involving tribal aborigines are rated *
Queen, Ellery O USA (East Coast) 1920's - 1960's Pseudonym of Frederic Dannay and Manfred Lee. Only novels published prior to WWII are rated *
Kerr, Philip PI Germany and Argentina. 1930's - 1940's Only the novels featuring 'Gunther' are rated **
Chandler, Raymond PI USA (California) 1930's - 1950's
Hare, Cyril O England 1930's - 1950's "Tenant for Death"is not recommended.
Innes, Michael PO England 1930's - 1960's? Clever plotting; socially and intellectually snobbish
Crispin, Edmund O England 1930's - 1970's Style dated but plottng clever and some mildly droll humour
Simenon, Georges (T) PO France (mainly) 1930's - 1970's Only novels featuring 'Maigret' are of interest as crime fiction. Novels set in the US are not rated ***.
Himes, Chester PO USA (Harlem) 1940's - 1960's
Macdonald, Ross PI USA (California) 1940's - 1970's
Waugh, Hillary PO USA (Connecticutt) 1940's - 1970's Only novels featuring 'Fellows' are rated **; others are rated *.
Gores, Joe PI USA (California) 1950's - Only novels featuring 'Kearney' are rated *

 

 

« Previous   |   1   |   2   |   3   |   4   |   5   |   6   |   7   |   8   |   Next »

 

Top of Page